Showing posts with label 06-StockMarkets. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 06-StockMarkets. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 28, 2008

Stock Markets - Reading

A reading of the essay below.


Tuesday, May 27, 2008

Stock Markets

In this module we begin with a disclaimer. Students new to the study of economics perk up when the discussion turns to the stock market. They think they'll learn something practical --- how to make money. Unfortunately for them, this module is not meant as a primer on investing and, even if it were, there are no quick and sure fire methods for doing well in the stock market. The main purpose of this module is to consider the stock market from the perspective of supply and demand and to contrast the stock market to the other markets we have considered.

Nonetheless, we recognize there is enormous fascination with creating personal wealth via financial investments and that those who lack experience in this area may very well be drawn to some self-education efforts. Further, we should encourage that, because having the experiential knowledge will help in understanding the economics. Have you every bought or sold assets in the stock market? Do you feel comfortable with your current knowledge of personal finance? Or would you like to increase your awareness?

Stock Markets - 2

If you do have substantial investment experience, you can breeze through the next content, so we'll proceed as if you haven't. One good source of personal investment advice is a solid book on the subject. A book will be most reflective on the underlying issues and thereby help that you don't get too caught up in the details of the subject or get too enthusiastic if you blindly luck into some early success investing. There are also some well designed Web sites that provide basic investment information and are a little easier to access. A third alternative is to try a simulation online so you can go through the motions of trading and get the informational feedback from that, but not experience the (possibly adverse) financial consequences from your decisions.

Since a couple of these alternatives require you to spend a few dollars (or to make some effort to go to the Library to get the book) please note that we are not promoting any one of these alternatives as the best way or even as a good way to self-educate. Instead, in each case you can take the listed alternative as representative of a genre. Then feel free to find different sources in a search engine or an online book store for other like alternatives that you deem better, more accessible, or more desirable in some other dimension. The real key is to get some of the basics about investing. If the path in getting there works for you, then it works.

Investment book by well known finance professor
A Random Walk Down Wall Street

Web Site
CNN and Money Magazine Investment Basics

Virtual Stock Exchange
Manage a Portfolio or Play an Investment Game

Now let's turn to the supply and demand perspective. Because the stock market is about the buying and selling of assets it shares certain properties with housing markets. After all, homes are also assets and as we've indicated most people who play in the housing market game do so as buyer (of the new home) and seller (of the old home). Likewise in the stock market, where assets are purchased and later sold. One significant difference between the two is that with housing we focus on the consumption value (the benefit from living in the home) and think of the asset value issue as secondary, while with stocks there is essentially no consumption value issue to consider; stocks are all about asset value. In other words, even if you like to drink Coke, you might very well buy Pepsi stock, thinking that stock will do well in the market. Your choices about which assets to buy and sell are driven by asset return considerations, not your consumption preferences.

This is not to say your experiences as consumer doesn't affect your views as investor. If you get good service from a company, you might value it. But the consumption experience and investor expectation are not directly correlated.

Here are two other areas where stock markets are different from housing markets. Stocks are a homogeneous product. One share of common stock in a company is a perfect substitute for another share of common stock in that same company. Stock markets are centralized, with the trade occurring on a "Stock Exchange." Because of these two key features, homogeneity and centralized trading, stock markets (and other financial markets) are sometimes considered the closest entities in actuality to the textbook ideal of a market. In essence, these markets are always in competitive equilibrium.

A stock may trade on multiple exchanges. There may be Market Makers who trade in the stock as well as computer systems called ECNs. Centralization is not perfect.

SEC on Trade Execution
SEC on Market Makers

One of the salient facts about stock market prices is that they change over time. Just to convince yourself of the truth of this fact, follow the link to the NASDAQ, choose call letters for a stock you know or do a symbol lookup to find the call letters or use msft (Microsoft). Then go to the pull down menu and get a Summary Quote. What type of pricing information does the summary quote return? How do those prices differ?

NASDAQ

Stock Markets - 3

There are a variety of prices at which transactions have occurred. The last sale is the most recent transaction that has been recorded into the system. There is also the high and the low, typically reached earlier in the day. The last should be somewhere between these two. Also included is the previous day's closing price. Yesterday's close can stand in any relation to today's high and low. Also included are best bid (the highest limit offer from buyers) and best ask (the lowest limit offer from sellers). These should sandwich the last transaction price with the best bid lower than the best ask. These limit orders have not yet been executed. And there should be a little graph of price versus time of day. Note that there are fluctuations in the graph. It is not a horizontal line.

If the market is always in equilibrium and yet the price changes over the course of the day this means the equilibrium must change, which in turn means that either supply or demand also must change over the course of the day. Before asking why this is the case, let's simply summarize that point. The statement that the market is in equilibrium and that disequilibrium trade does not occur has nothing to do with whether prices vary over time. Disequilibrium trading means that at the prevailing price either some buyers can't buy or some buyers can't sell (or that there is involuntary accumulation or reduction of stocks so that trade is accommodated). Equilibrium pricing means that at the prevailing price all agents that want to can (and therefore do) trade.

There is an issue whether disequilibrium is created over night when the market closes and if it persists into the opening the next morning. Actually, the current global system is close to but not exactly like a single never closing market.

SEC Study on ECNs and After Hours Trading

If the future could be predicted perfectly asset prices wouldn't vary much and then would change only as fundamentals changed. Of course, we can't predict the future. Instead, we guess at it. We form expectations of what might happen and those expectations are usually an amalgam of various scenarios, each possible and each of which excludes the other. As we gather information our views change. We rethink the likelihood of certain future events in the wake of the news and change our expectations as a consequence. Thus, it is the arrival of "news" and the processing of new information that drives the changes in supply and demand in the stock markets.

One of the "fun" ways to see how news affects asset values is by considering sports polls. If a highly rated team in the polls loses, its rating (which is like an asset price) likely will fall. If a less highly rated team has convincing wins over a rated team, the less highly rated team will rise in the ratings. Why is that?

College Football Poll
College Basketball Poll

Stock Markets - 4

Observe that the polls represent the votes of many (sportswriters for the AP poll, coaches for the ESPN poll) and what drives the voting of any individual in the poll is perhaps quite idiosyncratic. But we can model their decision. Suppose teams have intrinsic qualities that can't be directly observed. All that we can observe is how the teams do when they play each other. The outcome in any particular game depends on the qualities of the two teams, some other known factors like which is the home team, and a lot of random factors. Luck definitely comes into it. That means after the fact one can infer something about the hidden team quality based on the outcome of the game. The usual inference is that a win indicates your team is as good or better than you thought and a loss indicates the opposite. But everyone can have a bad day and a mediocre team can really shine on occasion.

Following Eugene Fama, a Professor of Finance at the University of Chicago's Graduate School of Business and father of the "Efficient Market Hypothesis" most economists believe that the stock market efficiently utilizes all the current information available. The main implication of that theory is that an investor can't consistently outperform a representative index (such as the S&P 500) of overall market activity. An occasional higher than market performance must be attributed to luck and chance factors. The efficient market hypothesis implies that periods of irrational exuberance, "bubbles" if you will, don't actually happen. If Fama is right, the expression "bubble" is simply an ex post rationalization.

A great Michael Lewis article about a stock dealer who came around to the Fama viewpoint
.

Fama versus the Behaviorists


Let us see how rational a decision maker you are. You are to consider the following scenario about Linda and then you must rank the three alternatives according to their likelihood, from most likely to least likely. Also provide a brief explanation for your rankings. Linda is thirty-one years old, single, outspoken, and very bright. She majored in philosophy. As a student, she was deeply concerned with issues of discrimination and social justice, and also participated in anti-nuclear demonstrations.
1. Linda is active in the feminist movement;
2. Linda is a bank teller;
3. Linda is a bank teller and is active in the feminist movement.

Stock Markets - 5

Now it simply must be true that the third statement is least likely, since any conjunction has to be less probable than either of its parts considered separately. Everybody can understand this when the principle is explained explicitly and patiently. But all groups of subjects, sophisticated students who ought to understand logic and probability as well as folks off the street corner, rank the last statement as more probable than the second. (I am particularly fond of this example because I know that the third statement is least probable, yet a little homunculus in my head continues to jump up and down, shouting at me—"but she can't just be a bank teller; read the description.")

The example with Linda as well as this paragraph and the next in response come from an article by Stephen Jay Gould on Joe Dimaggio's 56 game hitting streak.
Gould in New York Review of Books

Why do we so consistently make this simple logical error? Tversky and Kahneman argue, correctly I think, that our minds are not built (for whatever reason) to work by the rules of probability, though these rules clearly govern our universe. We do something else that usually serves us well, but fails in crucial instances: we "match to type." We abstract what we consider the "essence" of an entity, and then arrange our judgments by their degree of similarity to this assumed type. Since we are given a "type" for Linda that implies feminism, but definitely not a bank job, we rank any statement matching the type as more probable than another that only contains material contrary to the type. This propensity may help us to understand an entire range of human preferences, from Plato's theory of form to modern stereotyping of race or gender.

To sum up here, most economists believe in efficient markets and that there is no way to "beat the market." Occasionally an investor will have a stock that significantly out performs the market for a period and certainly that same investor will have some turkeys (poor performers), but on average doing as well as the market is the best an investor can hope for. One implication of this view is that if you have a balanced portfolio then sitting on it and not trading does as well as constantly trading. There are some economists who do occasionally believe the market gets out of wack, either over heated or under valued, and anyone who argues that way almost surely cites the work of Tversky and Kahneman about why people are not fully rational animals but rather make systematic errors with probabilities.

Let's turn to an issue that has already come up. We talk about stock indices and how the market as a whole performs. What are stock indices? How is the index calculated? Can you name some of these? Why is there interest in stock indices? How does the return on an individual stock compare to the return on a stock index?

Stock Markets - 6

The most well known stock index is probably the Dow Jones Industrial Average. It is a price average of 30 different stocks, with each of the thirty counting equally in the computation. In that respect the Dow is different from other indices, where the weights are proportional to the capitalization of the stock, so a more heavily capitalized stock is weighted more. (And note that the capitalization does vary as the stock price varies.) For the Dow, the 30 stocks that make up the index don't change much over time, for otherwise intertemporal comparisons of index value wouldn't be very useful. In the case of the Dow, the editorial board of the Wall Street Journal would have to choose to replace one of the 30 stocks with some alternative. The stocks that are there are chosen because they are deemed representative of some sector. The S&P 500 is a broader index (ergo the 500 in the name). Note that the stocks which constitute the index do change over time, if for no other reason than because of merger and acquisition.

Indices are used as benchmarks for performance, e.g., stock so-and-so outperformed the Dow over period such-and-such by x per cent. Some variation in stock prices is due to overall stock market performance while some is due to variation within a particular industry and the remainder in variation is attributable to performance of the specific firm. Knowing how the index did gives the individual investor the ability to parse out the industry and firm-specific components to the stock return.

Dow
Changes in the S&P 500


Please put any questions or comments about this module in the text box below.

Stock Markets - Discussion Question

Owners in a Proprietorship or a General Partnership face unlimited liability for all debts of the business. But publicly traded corporations have limited liability for shareholders, generally they can lose no more than their shares. Why have limited liability?

Stock Markets - Extension and Critique of the Essay

Stocks - Equity
Bonds - Debt
Debt/Equity Ratio
Asset Value Risk
Default Risk